The Brightness reimagines campus life through a feminist lens
Chad Harbach's long-awaited sequel, The Brightness, returns to Westish College with a feminist plotline about campus sexual assault that draws national scrutiny, set against the political backdrop of 2015.

Chad Harbach's new novel, The Brightness, continues the fictional Westish College universe from his acclaimed 2011 debut, The Art of Fielding. Set in 2015 on the brink of Donald Trump's first presidency and the global #MeToo movement, the 600-plus page sequel captures a campus grappling with power, consent, and justice. It features returning characters like baseball player-turned-author Owen Dunne and introduces a feminist plotline that sparks national controversy.
Westish College, a fictional midwestern liberal arts school whose baseball team is the Harpooners, remains the central setting. The story unfolds in the same realist, multi-perspective mode as its predecessor. In the four years of Westish time between the novels, Owen Dunne has written and published a bestselling novel titled The Art of Fielding, a meta-joke referencing Harbach's own work.
Feminist activism drives campus conflict
A feminist project conceived by three students ignites the central conflict. Nerdy scholarship student Irma Friske and her friends, the magnetic Pammy Chang and troubled Dahlia Breughel, are dubbed the 'Witches of Westish'. At a start-of-semester party, they plot to draw attention to campus sexual assault. Their scheme involves seducing and drugging football players and tattooing a shocking phrase across the players' foreheads. The fallout from this prank spreads far beyond the campus, attracting negative attention from national press, including a Fox News program hosted by a Tucker Carlson-like figure.
Political and cultural context shapes narrative
The novel is steeped in the era's politics. Key character moments are woven with references to Barack Obama, the Obergefell v. Hodges marriage equality decision, Donald Trump, Hillary Clinton, and Bernie Sanders. Harbach steps back from imposing an overarching plot, letting his characters navigate their uncertainty. The narrative is closer to a picaresque than a quest. As one character reflects, "To be in your 20s is to not quite know what the story’s about … You can’t see any shape to it." The author also shifts his literary allegiance from Herman Melville, whose statue presides over campus, to Shakespeare, with The Tempest serving as a deeper conversation about writing one's own story.
Critical reception highlights structural concerns
Reviewers have noted the book's substantial length and uneven pacing. The first part, focusing on the Witches' plot, is cited as the most engaging. Critics describe the final two parts as a dull and emotionally detached 100-page denouement filled with flashbacks and off-stage events. Some also question the novel's perspective on campus sexual assault, suggesting it presents investigations as disfavoring accusers, contrary to the pressure applied by the Obama administration. The narrative references the retracted 2014 Rolling Stone article 'A Rape on Campus'.
The story follows an ensemble cast including 28-year-old recent graduate Pella Affenlight, her father's former boyfriend Owen Dunne, and Irma's fiancé Mike Schwartz, a former catcher now working for the athletic department. Complex relationships unfold: Pella has an affair with Nicholas Byrnes, the son of a once-prominent feminist, after finding Mike in bed with another woman. Irma grapples with her attraction to both the idolized Dahlia and the handsome but dull Nicholas. The novel explores themes of agency, with Irma and Dahlia wanting to write their own stories like Prospero, while Pella reflects that you cannot proceed from a shaping wish of how things should be.
The Brightness concludes on a note of ambiguity, suggesting the entire story may be a construct of one of its characters. It ends with Irma and Pella trying to sort out their lives, sharing a vision of 'male-less motherhood' reminiscent of Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God.





